Element Archives – Refinance – Mortgage Refinancing Rates And Information

Underwater Mortgages and the Science of the Perfect Loan Modification

March 4th, 2010 No comments

Loan Modifications have taken over the financial news in the last year. This is not at all surprising, with over 11.3 million people, nearly 25 per cent of all homes, with underwater mortgages; this is an issue that has the nation’s attention.

This makes any research into the issue of loan modifications and their effect on foreclosure of great interest to borrowers, banks, and the government.

One professor whose research has received a lot of attention is Sanjiv Ranjan Das, from the University of Santa Clara in California. Last year Das attacked the underwater issue, this refers to borrowers whose mortgage balances are larger than the market value of their homes. The underwater issue is one of the big problems the United States housing market has to deal with.

Professor Sanjiv Ranjan Das had a large and interested audience to his research; one big fan was his namesake Sanjiv Das, a top executive at CitiMortgage, the fourth biggest bank in the US, lender and servicer of over seven hundred billion dollars in mortgages.

Interestingly, these two men, one a professor and the other a banker, share more than just a name. Not least among the things they have in common is an education at the Indian Institute of Management.

Now they are working together on research that seeks to explain the behavior of borrowers that are stuck with underwater homes, unemployment and mortgage payments they cannot afford.

Interestingly the partnership between the two Das, began when the professor started receiving emails meant for the CitiMortgage Das. However, the accidental emails were great for the research of Santa Clara’s professor.

According to Das’ research the perfect or optimal loan modification includes an element of forgiving some of the balance in the loan. This is not easy for bankers to accept. Reducing the balance of the loan increases the speed at which the bank must accept losses and there is the added fear that it will create a counterproductive culture among borrowers.

However research has shown that re-defaulting on mortgages is much higher among borrowers that do not receive a reduction of their mortgage balance. This is because having an underwater home, a house with negative equity, makes many homeowners feel there is no financial sense in keeping their homes. However, when a principal reduction is carried out, even if only a modest one, re-defaulting on mortgages is sharply reduced.

Nevertheless lenders still shy away from this radical loan modification method and prefer using interest rate reductions and term extensions to reduce the monthly payments of troubled homeowners.

The good news is that the research carried out is getting the attention of the right people. The more is studied about the effects of income shock, or wealth shock, on troubled borrowers the more effective loan modifications and debt management as whole will be.

Share At:

Hide Sites

Loan Modifications With Principal Cuts Attract Lenders Attention

January 13th, 2010 No comments

Loan Modification consultants have being saying it for a long time; the best loan modifications are those that reduce the balance of the loan. This might seem obvious; of course borrowers are going to prefer loan modifications that reduce the amount they owe. What is not so obvious is that these types of loan modifications may be the best kind for lenders too.

Loan Modifications can use a variety of tools and measures to reduce the monthly payments of a mortgage. Reducing monthly payments is considered to be the main objective of a loan modification, as a way of giving troubled borrowers a break so they can continue to pay their mortgage. This can be done by:

1) Reducing the interest rate of the mortgage, either temporarily or permanently.

2) Extending the term of the loan, which means giving the borrower longer to pay the loan back.

3) Rolling interest payments to the end of the loan, this reduces monthly payments but creates a huge payment at the end of the loan.

4) Principal reductions of the loan balance. Here the bank or lender “forgives” or writes off a portion of the loan.

The Obama Administration does not control which measures lenders use on loan modifications and they certainly don’t require lenders to cut mortgage principals, what’s more, until recently principal reductions seemed unthinkable, a nice idea but not very practical. It must be said that forgiving debts is a nice thing for friends to do, but it doesn’t sound like a good way for lenders to do business.

However, recent reports are showing that principal reductions could be a key factor in creating cost efficient loan modifications for both lenders and borrowers. One of these reports was published by the Lender Processing Services June 2009 Mortgage Monitor and concluded that re-defaults on loan modifications with a principal reduction element fare much better than those based exclusively on interest rate reductions. The report states that “the success rate for loss mitigation-related loan modification hovers in the 30-40% range, with a higher success rate for loan modifications involving a reduction in unpaid balance.

The success rates of loan modifications with principal reductions is so much better than with other methods that lenders are beginning to listen to the data and increasing their principal reductions on mortgages of troubled borrowers.

You might still ask yourself why banks or lenders would be willing to cut unpaid loan balances instead of using other apparently cheaper measures. The key, we hinted at above, are foreclosures. Foreclosures are expensive for lenders, selling in a buyers’ market and the costs associated with selling a property are not cheap. Having said that any kind of loan modification carried out to avoid foreclosure is expensive for lenders whether they reduce interest rates, extend the term of the loan or reduce the principal balance, what makes it even worse is when borrowers re-default on their loans after the loan modification. Because foreclosure re-defaults are much lower on loan modifications with principal reductions, lenders are starting to think they might be cheaper in the long run, which is good news for the fortunate few that actually qualify for a loan modification.

Share At: